The delusion of the lefty elitist

EJ Dionne, one of my favorite melancholy liberals, has a piece where he blows his trumpet, calling forth the progressives to a new utopia of liberal ideas that have been mandated by the collapse of the Republican Majority.

EJ’s ideas are, well, flawed, and they are flawed primarily in the premise that there’s a great, unmotivated mass of US voters who are just itching to vote progressive. The 2006 elections proved it– Reagan conservatism was dead! It’s now time to sweep people into office and fulfill the unrealized liberal dream because that’s what the people want!

Dionne wants the left to present the progressive ideas as something which will transform America. The ideas of universal health care, social security, exemplary education– everything that would make America a shining beacon of intellectual prowess to the world. Dionne wants the Left to help everyone realize it. (The fact he’s publishing in the Chronicle of Higher Education and quoting numerous books by academic sociologists and political scientists should be an indicator that he’s appealing to the intellectuals and not the common man. Dionne wants educators to carry the banner of fostering the New Liberal revolution, not the poor, the oppressed, or the minority. It’s an important distinction, especially when you consider the audience– rich, elitists intellectual white men and women– oh, the same label that’s been applied to the conservatives who have been running the country.)

Dionne doesn’t think that the opportunity here is a giant shift towards liberalism in the country, but more of a Republican collapse. That Dionne wants to impress the Liberal Ideal as a platform, however, is something ludicrous and at odds with the fundamental premise. If the electorate is upset with incompetent politicians on the right, then they’re not upset with conservative ideals.

I think it is safe to say that America would not be disgruntled about the Iraq war had there been a clear strategy for post-war Iraq that was coherent and working. I’m sure that a swifter departure of Rummy and a faster implementation of Prateus’ strategies would have swung the tide of the 2006 election. I would also wager that had there not been a myriad of scandals involving Republicans, and had there been a reduction of the national debt, and a solid solution implemented for social security, that we’d have a majority of Republicans in Congress.

Instead, between 2002 and 2006 we were treated to the same-old same-old in D.C. As John Stossel notes, Republican Congresses have been notoriously bad about balancing a budget and keeping government growth in check. What was experienced in 2006 was a frustration with the status-quo and a desire to clean Congress of corrupt and incompetent politicians. What’s clear from the poll numbers is a national disgust with the Democrat Congress, primarily because they didn’t understand why the voters were so angry.

Dionne’s premise that a Liberal Revolution will create a golden era for progressives is simply silly. The country wants numerous issues addressed, and doing what the country doesn’t want you to do is causing more problems than it’s solving.

I think we’ll see Democratic gains in the Senate in 2008, but losses in the House, granted the Republicans can (and should) challenge successfully based on the backwards policies of the Pelosi leadership. But unless Republicans (or Democrats) can actually get passed those powers that have controlled their leadership for the past 40 years, we’re not going to see a pleased electorate anytime soon.

If the Reform party was still coherent, I’d think that they would stand a very good chance of actually taking seats in 2008, much to the chagrin of EJ Dionne.


0 Responses to “The delusion of the lefty elitist”

  1. Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

About Me

My name is Doc. Welcome to my blog. If you're visiting from another blog, add me to your blogroll (and I'll happily reciprocate). I have a Ph.D. in Chemistry and live in Wisconsin. If you have any questions, feel free to email me. My email is docattheautopsy at gmail. (No linking to deflate the incredible spam monsters).



World Temp Widget

Blog Stats

  • 131,633 hits

RSS The Autopsy

The Autopsy

%d bloggers like this: